Labour reveals local councils unable to help 96% of people affected by bedroom tax

Hot on the heels of Weoley’s bedroom tax meeting last month, the Labour Party has revealed that 13,557 Birmingham households are affected by the tax but there are just 368 suitable properties they could downsize to.

Birmingham MPs Jack Dromey and Richard Burden join Weoley's Steve Booton to discuss the hated bedroom tax

Birmingham MPs Jack Dromey and Richard Burden join Weoley’s Steve Booton to discuss the hated bedroom tax

More than 96% of people hit by the tax have nowhere to move to, forcing already vulnerable people to food banks and loan sharks. There is now a serious danger it could end up costing Britain more than it saves as tenants are forced into homelessness or the expensive private rented sector.

Steve Booton, Weoley candidate, said: “The bedroom tax must be scrapped and more affordable homes built for people to rent; creating jobs, giving young people training opportunities, and putting money back into the economy to get this country on its feet again.

“Week after week, we meet people on our street stall who are victims of the Tory bedroom tax. They can’t move because there aren’t the properties available to meet their needs, yet they’re being made to pay for a crisis they have not created. The local Tory councillors might talk about Labour shedding crocodile tears, but those tears are feeling increasingly real: research shows that the disabled are among the most victimised under this unfair and unjust tax.”

Housing shortfall for those affected by bedroom tax

Housing shortfall for those affected by bedroom tax*

Steve invited Shadow Housing Minister Jack Dromey MP and Northfield MP Richard Burden to speak to local Weoley residents about the hated bedroom tax in July. Jack Dromey, also a Birmingham MP, told residents that the tax was not based on sound economics but built on an inhuman narrative of ‘them and us’.

He said: “We’ve had a housing crisis for 30 years. We don’t need people now to be forced into expensive private sector houses that will increase the housing benefits bill further. What is driving the increase in benefits are high rents coupled with in-work benefits paid to people on low wages.”

Richard Burden said: “The truth is there aren’t enough smaller homes for families to move to – at least not at a price that people can afford. Many now can’t afford to stay in their home but can’t afford to move.”

* Fellow Birmingham MP Liam Byrne made the Freedom of Information requests that show that local councils are unable to help 96% of tenants affected by the bedroom tax due to a major shortage of available housing.

In 26 local authority areas, 99,079 households have seen their benefits cut due to having a spare room in their home. These new figures reveal that there are just 3,803 one and two-bedrooms homes for them to move to.


Spending Review 2013: pain without gain for Birmingham residents

Sir Albert Bore

Sir Albert Bore: ‘pain without gain’

While some are out finding out whether locals think “we” are on the right track after the Tory Chancellor announced a further year of even larger cuts, Sir Albert Bore commented this afternoon that the government’s austerity project has failed to regenerate the economy and thrown the coalition promises of 2010 completely off course.

Chancellor George Osborne this afternoon unveiled a further £11.5bn of cuts to public spending in his 2013 Spending Review for 2015/16.

Responding to news that local authorities face a further two years of the council tax freeze imposed by central government and a 10 per cent budget cut, Sir Albert, Birmingham City Council Leader, said: “In the Comprehensive Spending Review of 2010, the Government planned to implement cuts up to 2014/15, by which time they thought the budget deficit would be under control.

“The Spending Round and further cuts to public services in 2015/16 have happened because there has been little growth in the economy, throwing these forecasts completely off course.

“Instead of bringing the deficit under control, it has been very similar for the last two years and actually increased slightly in 2012/13. This is because of the lack of growth in the economy. So we have had the pain of the cuts but not the gain of sorting out the deficit.

“Local government has already endured the biggest cuts in funding ever seen. It will have been cut by a third, whilst the average cut across government departments is 12 per cent.

“Councils have achieved astonishing efficiency savings and shed around half a million staff very quickly, with many more redundancies to come. In Birmingham, we have already saved around £275m and are making a further £100m of savings this year. We have lost around a quarter of our workforce since 2010. We now anticipate £80m of grant cuts in 2014/15, growing to £151m in 2015/16.

“But the scope for efficiency savings is rapidly disappearing and councils are already cutting front-line services and having to consider bigger cuts in the next year. The further year of even larger cuts will make it even more difficult to maintain vital local services.

“We do welcome the additional money that will be received to help fund social care, although at this stage the details are unclear.

“However, the logic of the Government’s approach is that cuts will continue at this pace for another two years at least – leading to the Jaws of Doom scenario in which we lose over 50 per cent of our controllable budget between 2011 and 2018.

“This is an unsustainable approach that will have dire consequences for local communities and threaten the viability of many councils. Instead, the Government should work with us to rewire public services and ensure that they can be provided in the years ahead.

“This requires opening up departmental budgets, localising them and pooling them under more local control. The Government must be much more radical in this respect: the crisis is now – not in a decade’s time.”

Birmingham City Council wins extra funding for council tax support

Council tax benefit claimants in Birmingham will have the impact of one of central government’s welfare reforms softened after £2.1m extra funding was secured by the city council, following successful negotiations with the government.

This additional Council Tax Support funding means that 47,000 working-age claimants will now have to pay a maximum of just 8.5% of their Council Tax in 2013/14 – rather than 20%.

When setting this year’s budget, the council projected that £1.5 million of savings would need to be made elsewhere to ensure that the liability was just 8.5%.

However, following a decision to freeze Council Tax and further negotiations with the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) for extra funding, this is now feasible.

Cllr Ian Ward, Deputy Leader of Birmingham City Council, said: “We have always wanted to protect the most vulnerable in our city, but the government’s localisation of Council Tax Support means we have less money and our finances cannot stretch to support people as we have in the past.

“It is pleasing that we have successfully argued our case for extra funding, but we have to be clear this is a one-off grant – only for one year – so we are going to face some very tough decisions again in the future.

“We will continue to argue Birmingham’s case in respect of the impacts of welfare reform, but we have to be realistic about likely future scenarios.”

Full details on the backdating of the enhanced support to 1 April 2013 will be made available in the near future.

Reproduced from Birmingham Newsroom

The do-nothing culture of the Conservative-led government

Richard Burden, Northfield MP, reacts to today’s Queen’s Speech:

Earlier today (8th May) was the State Opening of Parliament, where the Queen formally opens the new Parliamentary Session with a speech setting out the Government’s agenda and priorities for the next year.

Unfortunately as anticipated the Queen’s Speech, which was one of the shortest in years, failed to recognise many of the problems concerning real people. It was a stark reminder that this out of touch Conservative-led Government has its priorities completely wrong.

Today was an opportunity to change course and get Britain back on track, to support working people by lowering the cost of living or tackling increases in energy bills and train fares. Instead the speech offered no change and was short of ideas.

The Government claims its focus is the economy, but sadly the speech mentioned nothing about tackling youth unemployment or pressing banks to lend more to small businesses.

The speech failed to reflect the need for more action to be taken on housing. Not only does the housing shortage need addressing by building more homes, but clearer and stronger regulations are needed in the private rented sector to stop rogue landlords charging extortionate fees.

I was also disappointed to see the omission of efforts to protect our health, by introducing minimum alcohol pricing and plain packaging for cigarettes, from the speech. It is just another example of a shy Government too afraid to stand up to big industries.

Over 5,000 young people in Birmingham have been out of work for more than 6 months. Each day a growing number of people in Northfield are getting in touch with me about their housing troubles.  The Government rhetoric has emphasised stopping the so called ‘something for nothing’ culture. But too often it is them doing nothing. As far as I’m concerned it’s the Conservative-led Government that need to do something.

You can read One Nation Labour’s alternative Queen’s Speech – one that is committed to jobs and growth here.

Wiping away Weoley’s ‘crocodile tears’ – when your home is not your own

While nearly half a million people are calling on Iain Duncan Smith to put his money where his mouth is, 430 of the poorest families in Weoley will be forced to pay higher rent or move home.

The bedroom tax will cause untold damage to our communities in Weoley, where families who receive housing benefit and live in council or housing association homes with a ‘spare’ bedroom will have to pay around £600 more a year or risk being forced to move home.

The Northfield Constituency, made up of Weoley, Kings Norton, Longbridge and Northfield wards, is one of the worst hit areas in Birmingham with around 1,400 properties affected. Over the past few months, Steve Booton, Weoley Labour Party spokesperson, and Richard Burden, MP for Northfield, have been inundated with requests for help from local residents deeply concerned that they will not be able to afford the extra charges on surplus bedrooms.

Steve Booton said: “What worries us in the Weoley Labour Party is that this policy will force already poor people into further financial hardship if they decide to stay put or it will displace entire communities if they decide they have to find an alternative property.”

Richard Burden said: “We’re finding countless situations where the bedroom tax will hit soldiers and pensioners and two thirds of the families affected are home to someone with a disability. If families are made homeless or pushed into expensive private rented accommodation, the taxpayer could actually be left with a higher bill.”

Crocodile tears

In a recent Birmingham City Council webcast, Conservative Cllr Peter Douglas Osborn was seen to publicly back the bedroom tax. Mr Douglas Osborn, by doing this, shows a complete disregard for some of the most vulnerable families in his own Weoley ward.

Cllr Douglas Osborn faced criticism from fellow committee members when he warned against shedding crocodile tears for tenants who face a ‘downgrade’ once the kids leave home and said that the term bedroom tax was ‘long on emotion and very short on fact.’

Steve Booton said: “It’s typical of Cllr Douglas Osborn to back this unjust policy when everyone knows there are not enough of the right-sized properties for people to move into. After all, the Tories are now known as the party of the rich.

“We met a woman on our street stall on Saturday who has been trying to move for years. She now faces an extra £28 a week rent. She and many others will see their benefits reduced further by changes to council tax payments and legal aid is now also outside the grasp of ordinary people.

“So whether it’s pushing people into private rented accommodation via the bedroom tax, punishing the vulnerable with welfare cuts or asset-stripping the NHS, Douglas Osborn and his Tory friends are out to make sure the rich make a profit while the poor pay more.”

Northfield District Committee meeting, live streamed on Friday 22 March 2013 at 2pm

Save the date

Councillor James McKayWeoley Labour has invited Councillor James McKay to meet the people of Weoley to discuss the new wheelie bin project.

The consultation will take place on 23rd April. More information about venue and time will follow shortly.

In the meantime, why not have a look at our previous post that includes a video of Cllr McKay, Cabinet Member for a Green, Safe and Smart City, explaining what the scheme means for Birmingham?

Online survey opens on wheelie bins in Brum

An online survey for Birmingham residents has kicked off the six-month consultation on wheelie bins.

Wheelie bin survey

Paper-based copies of the document will also be made available in the near future at all 40 city council libraries and 21 customer service centres/neighbourhood offices.

Cllr James McKay, Cabinet Member for a Green, Safe and Smart City, said:

“We have been clear from the outset that we will listen to citizens as we shape the finer points of the scheme – and we have also been clear that this process is not about if we have wheelie bins, it’s about getting the best wheelie bin scheme for Birmingham.

“I urge people to get involved over the coming months because the more information we get, the better chance we have of making the city as clean and green as possible.”

Birmingham City Council has also promised a host of other measures in the coming weeks and months, including:

  • Consultation through the Citizens Panel
  • Consultation with specialist groups such as people with disabilities, the elderly, Registered Social Landlords, Housing Liaison Boards, and Conservation Areas
  • All 10 District Committees and the Ward Committees in the two pilot wards – Brandwood and Harborne
  • Pre and post-wheelie bin delivery face-to-face consultation with a sample of residents in the two pilot wards

The feedback gathered from all these channels will be used to shape the final scheme, which will see the current system of sacks and boxes eventually replaced by two wheeled bins for every household, with an optional third for green waste. There will be exemptions where wheelie bins are not appropriate.

To complete the online survey, go to

What wheelies mean for Weoley

Birmingham City Council has won more than £29 million worth of funding that will allow the City to keep weekly bin collections and increase recycling.

The Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) told Birmingham council officers that the city’s bid – based on introducing wheeled bins for Birmingham’s households – had excelled in all areas.

Birmingham Cllr James McKay, Cabinet Member for a Green, Safe and Smart City, said: “Birmingham put forward an ambitious set of proposals that will preserve weekly waste collections, make our streets cleaner and help increase recycling rates. Now the Government has rallied behind our plans.”

“We will maintain our weekly collection. Wheeled bins will not be used in a small number of cases where they are impractical and assisted collections will continue. We know the issue of weekly collection is hugely important to citizens and for many it is seen as one of the key services the council provides”

Cllr McKay promised public consultation over the details of the bid to make sure the best possible scheme is introduced for all citizens, including the special provisions for properties that are unsuitable for a wheeled bin collection service or for those residents who would find it difficult or impossible to move a wheeled bin.

Eric Pickles, Secretary of State for Local Government, announced that over 6 million families will keep getting a weekly bin service thanks to the government’s Weekly Collection Support Scheme, ‘making sure council tax payers get good value for money’.

What the money will mean for Birmingham

Birmingham City Council answers your frequently asked questions about wheeled bins

Will the recent DCLG announcement of funding mean we will have wheeled bins in Birmingham?

Wheelie binYes.
This matter was debated by the City Council’s Cabinet on Monday 30th July 2012 and again on the 10th December 2012. The City Council have been awarded over £29 million by Central Government to introduce a wheeled bin collection service across Birmingham.

Will the Council look at the experience of Councils who have already introduced wheeled bins?

Wheeled bins are used in over 82% of all councils in England and there is a great deal of experience and knowledge about what works and what doesn’t – Birmingham will learn from this previous experience. This isn’t a unique project and all of the major cities in England already use wheeled bins.

What size bin will I receive?

It will be essential to ensure that households receive an appropriate sized container for their needs. It is recognised that some households, for example larger households, would need larger containers. The Council has not determined which size containers will be used but would look at what other local authorities do and determine how best to meet the needs of residents and the Council.

How many bins will I receive?

Up to 3 bins – one for waste, one for recycling and one for green waste (if required). We will be testing how the bins will be used in selected areas of the city. Adjustments may need to be made for individual property types and roads.

I don’t think my property is suitable for a wheeled bin.

We appreciate that not all properties are suitable for a wheeled bin collection service. Following the models from other councils, these include some properties that:

  • have a steep slope/many steps between the house and the street where it would be difficult to move a wheeled bin up or down
  • have no access or very limited access to the rear of the property, such as in some types of terraced housing
  • have no ground floor access, such as flats above shops and some maisonettes

In these circumstances, other councils make alternative arrangements such as retaining the collection system that was previously used.

What about elderly or disabled residents how will they manage?

We recognise that some residents would find it difficult or impossible to move a wheeled bin, such as a wheelchair user, and we will make alternative arrangements either through the provision of an ‘assisted’ service or again through providing a different type of collection service that meets the household’s needs.

Why are we changing black sacks if it already works well?

Whilst we appreciate your view that the current black sack system works perfectly well, independent research has shown that where a wheeled bin system has been introduced, recycling rates have increased.
Birmingham needs to reduce the amount of waste that we produce and to reuse and recycle more. Furthermore, the current system causes litter due to bags being ripped open by rodents, other animals and birds, with the contents strewn about the street.

When will the bins be introduced?

The bid to the DCLG outlined a 2 to 3 year timetable for the full procurement and roll-out of the bins. We intend to implement a pilot in spring 2013 in two wards looking at different options. The wards to be selected will be determined shortly.

Will my collection day change?

It is possible when wheeled bins are rolled out that collection days may change. However, it is not possible at this stage to give an indication of what those changes could be. All changes to days would be kept to a minimum.

Will wheeled bins result in redundancies?

No. It is anticipated the introduction will not cause job losses.

Who is responsible for keeping the bins clean?

The experience of other local authorities who have implemented this type of collection methodology is that residents place bagged waste into the wheeled bins and therefore there is minimal ongoing need to clean. If cleaning is required then it is the resident’s responsibility to undertake this.

Why are you not proposing to take food waste separately?

The Council is currently considering the feasibility of a separate food waste collection. In the future it may also be possible to co-collect food waste with garden waste and the three bins proposed would support this method of collection.
This is not part of the funding received as part of the DCLG bid. A separate consultation with residents would be undertaken if this option was considered further.

[This set of frequently asked questions (FAQs) has been reproduced from the Birmingham City council website.]

The council will soon be consulting Birmingham residents about the wheelie bin collection service. If you have any questions about the proposals, please email Or you can contact Steve and he’ll find out for you.